Jack Nicholson
Charley Partanna

Kathleen Turner
Irene Walker

Robert Loggia
Eduardo Prizzi

John Randolph
Angelo 'Pop' Partanna

William Hickey
Don Corrado Prizzi

Lee Richardson
Dominic Prizzi

Michael Lombard
Rosario Filargi " Finlay "

Anjelica Huston
Maerose Prizzi

Lawrence Tierney
Lt. Hanley

CCH Pounder
Peaches Altamont

Ann Selepegno
Amalia Prizzi

Vic Polizos
Phil Vittimizzare

Dick O'Neill
Bluestone

Sully Boyar
Casco Vascone

Antonia Vasquez
Theresa Prizzi

Tomasino Baratta
Opera Singer

John Calvani
Don's Bodyguard

Murray Staff
Gallagher

Joseph Ruskin
Marxie Heller

Raymond Serra
Bocca

Seth Allen
Alvin Gomsky

Dominic Barto
Presto Ciglione

Teddi Siddall
Beulah

Tom Signorelli
Photographer #2

Ray Iannicelli
Photographer #1

Stanley Tucci
Soldier

Themi Sapountzakis
Policeman

Debra Kelly
Bride at Mexican Chapel

Scott Campbell
Groom at Mexican Chapel

Beth Raines
Airport Clerk

Michael Sabin
Charley Partanna at 17

Michael Tuck
Anchorman "Fred"

Michael Fischetti
Kiely

Kenneth Cervi
Bodyguard

Marlene D. Williams
Mrs. Calhane

Joe Kopmar
Cigar Smoker #1

Erasmus C. Alfano
Cigar Smoker #2

Peter D'Arcy
Cigar Smoker #3

Thomas Lomanco
Cigar Smoker #4

Bill Brecht
Cigar Smoker #5

Enzo Citarelli
Priest

John P. Codiglia
Cop

Henry Fehren
Bishop

Alexandra Ivanoff
Soprano Soloist in Church

Skip O'Brien
Bartender

Theodore Theoharous
Priest

Jonathan L. Arland
Man #1 at Mexican Wedding

Rubén C. González
Man #2 at Mexican Wedding

Luis Accinelli
Man #3 at Mexican Wedding

Danielle Frederick
Woman #1 at Mexican Wedding

Garry Pastore
Usher #2 (Uncredited)

Nick Vallelonga
Arsonist (uncredited)