Amber Tamblyn
Tibby Rollins

Alexis Bledel
Lena Kaligaris

America Ferrera
Carmen Lowell

Blake Lively
Bridget Vreeland

Rachel Nichols
Julia Beckwith

Tom Wisdom
Ian

Rachel Ticotin
Christina Lowell

Leonardo Nam
Brian McBrian

Michael Rady
Kostas Dounas

Shohreh Aghdashloo
Professor Nasrin Mehani

Blythe Danner
Greta

Jesse Williams
Leo

Lucy Hale
Effie Kaligaris

Kyle MacLachlan
Bill Kerr (uncredited)

Μαρία Κωνσταντάρου
Yia Yia

Ernie Lively
Franz Vreeland

Stevie Ray Dallimore
Nigel O'Bannon

Alison Folland
Stage Manager Margaret

Zacharoula Klimatsaki
Melia

Nathaniel Martello-White
Dig Site Student Ray (as Nathaniel Martello)

Emmanuel Leconte
Dig Site Student Miles

Maryann Urbano
Art Teacher Annika (as Maryanne Urbano)

Paul Coughlan
David Breckman

Rebekah Aramini
Ariadne Kaligaris

Cory Nichols
Nicky Rollins

Carly Rose Sonenclar
Katherine Rollins

Erik Jensen
Video Store Manager Phil

Adrienne Bailon-Houghton
Cute Video Couple Girl

Cannon Smith
Cute Video Couple Guy

Dylan Jude Sheridan
Male Video Store Customer (as Dylan Sheridan)

Lindsay Michelle Nader
Female Video Store Customer (as Lindsay Nader)

Crystal McCrary
Mom with Screaming Kids (as Crystal McCrary Anthony)

Nicole Patrick
Apprentice Actor #1

Josh Caras
Apprentice Actor #2

Kiely Williams
Yaffa Waitress

Max Woertendyke
Yale Stagehand

Victor Slezak
Doctor

Marceline Hugot
Nurse

Harry L. Seddon
Tibby's Dad

Kendall Cross
Marlene Vreeland (uncredited)